Holiday Spending Forecasts Disagree. What Are They Measuring?
Holiday spending forecasts can sound contradictory. One survey may predict stronger seasonal sales while another says households are tightening their budgets. For US retailers and shoppers, both can be true because the reports may measure different things: total sales across the economy, a sample of consumer intentions, average planned gift budgets, or growth compared with a different baseline.
Table of Contents

Visa’s 2026 holiday outlook forecasts US retail sales, excluding automotive, to rise 4.5% from the prior year during November and December. Visa also reported that surveyed consumers planned to spend an average of $777 on gifts. Circana’s 2026 holiday study, by contrast, projects holiday spending could range from a 1% decline to a 2.5% increase and reports an average planned budget of $779. The figures are close in one respect, but the topline growth estimates are not interchangeable.
Why holiday spending forecasts can disagree
A forecast for retail sales estimates the value of transactions across a market. It can be affected by population, prices, product mix, store sales and the assumptions built into the model. A survey asking people how much they expect to spend measures intentions from a particular group of respondents. Intentions can change before checkout, and the results depend on who was asked and how questions were framed.
An average gift budget also does not describe every household. A small number of high spenders can pull an average upward, while a median or category-level breakdown might tell a different story. The reported $777 and $779 figures may seem precise, but neither is a recommended spending target. A family’s budget depends on income, savings, debt, travel plans and the number of people they shop for.

Why forecasters can reach different answers
Methodology matters. Visa’s estimate uses payment network data and economic modelling to project retail sales. Circana’s study surveys consumers about intended spending and considers shoppers’ plans across categories. Each approach has value, but one tracks an estimate of market activity while the other captures what respondents say they plan to do.
The comparison can also depend on what each report includes. Forecasts may treat online and in-store purchases, gift cards, restaurants, travel or automotive sales differently. Some figures are adjusted for inflation and some are nominal. Reports can use different holiday windows and compare them with distinct prior-year periods. Before describing a number as a broad consumer trend, check the report’s definition, date range and data source.
What shoppers can take from the reports
Use forecasts as context, not as a prompt to spend more. Set a limit that fits your own finances, list the purchases that matter most and include delivery, taxes and travel in the total. Compare an item’s current price with its recent history and read the return policy before ordering. If you are buying for a group, agree on a spending range early so the plan does not expand at the last minute.

For retailers, a positive sales forecast does not guarantee that every category or store will grow. Consumers can keep overall spending steady while switching to lower-priced products, waiting for promotions or buying fewer items. That can make sales dollars rise even while shoppers describe themselves as cautious. Average transaction value and unit volume can tell different stories.
Read the fine print in a forecast
When you see a seasonal projection, ask four questions: Does it describe planned spending or measured sales? Is the estimate adjusted for inflation? Which products and dates are included? Does the report publish a range or a single point estimate? Those details explain why a forecast is a scenario rather than a promise.
Visa’s 2026 holiday retail outlook provides its sales and gift-budget estimates, while Circana’s holiday study describes its consumer survey and spending range. Read each method before comparing the headlines. For a personal plan, your actual budget matters more than either national forecast.
Holiday spending forecasts can look contradictory when one measures shoppers’ stated plans and another tracks actual retail sales. Check the population, dates and spending categories before comparing them. For a shopper-focused seasonal guide, read Funzug’s Black Friday planning checklist.





